AuthorsJ. E. Hannay and M. Jørgensen
TitleThe Role of Artificial Design Elements in Software Engineering Experiments
AfilliationSoftware Engineering, Software Engineering
StatusPublished
Publication TypeJournal Article
Year of Publication2008
JournalIEEE Transactions on Software Engineering
Volume34
Number2
Pagination242-259
Date PublishedMarch/April
Abstract

Increased realism in software engineering experiments is often promoted as an important means to increase generalizability and industrial relevance. In this context, artificiality, e.g., the use of constructed tasks in place of realistic tasks, is seen as a threat. In this article, we examine the opposite view, that deliberately introduced artificial design elements may increase knowledge gain and enhance both generalizability and relevance. In the first part of the article, we identify and evaluate arguments and examples in favor of, and against, deliberately introducing artificiality into software engineering experiments. In the second part of the article, we summarize a content analysis of articles reporting software engineering experiments published over the ten-year period 1993-2002. The analysis reveals a striving for realism and external validity, but little awareness of for what and when, various degrees of artificiality and realism are appropriate. We conclude that an increased awareness and deliberation in these respects is essential. However, arguments in favor of artificial design elements should not be used to justify studies that are badly designed or that have research questions of low relevance.

Citation KeySimula.SE.9